āDicunt ei : CƦsaris. Tunc ait illis : Reddite ergo quƦ sunt CƦsaris, CƦsari : et quƦ sunt Dei, Deo.ā
āThey say unto him, Caesar's. Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's.ā
āāCaesarās,ā they answered. So Jesus told them, āGive to Caesar what is Caesarās, and to God what is Godās.āā
āThey said to him, āCaesarās.ā Then he said to them, āGive therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesarās, and to God the things that are Godās.āā
āThey say unto him, Caesar's. Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's.ā
Render therefore to CÄsar the things that are CÄsarās. He neither directly decided the question, nor offended the Herodians. They admired his wisdom, were quite disappointed, and retired with confusion. (Witham) ā The reasoning of Christ appears to be this: As you are the subjects of CÄsar, which you plainly acknowledge by admitting his coin, upon which he inscribes himself lord of Asia, Syria, and JudÄa, &c. it is but just you pay him the tribute due from subjects to their sovereign; nor have you any reason to object on the plea of religion, since he demands of you for the exigencies of the public service only temporal things, and such as are in some respects already his own, by being stamped with his own image and superscription. But spiritual things, which belong to God alone, as your souls, stamped with his image, divine worship, religious homage, &c. God, not CÄsar, demands of you. āGive therefore to CÄsar what belongeth to CÄsar, and to God what belongeth to God.ā (Tirinus) ā What our Saviour here commands us to give to God, is nothing else but our heart and affections. Here our divine Lord likewise shews us, how we are to steer the middle course between the two extremes, into which some persons fall. Some say that all must be given to God, and nothing to CÄsar, i.e. all our time must be given to the care of our soul, and none to the care of the body; but Christ teaches that some must be given to the one, and part to the other. (Origen) ā Although Christ clearly establishes here the strict obligation of paying to CÄsar what belongs to CÄsar, yet he is afterwards accused, as we have mentioned above, (see note on ver. 17) as if he forbade tribute to be paid to CÄsar. In like manner, in spite of the most explicit declarations of the Catholic Church, respecting her loyalty and subjection to temporal powers, her enemies fail not to calumniate her doctrine as inimical to the state, and subversive of due subordination. But let our opponents attend to the following authority and public declaration of Pope Clement XIV. addressed to all Catholic bishops in the Christian world. āBe careful,ā says he, āthat those whose instruction in the law of the gospel is committed to your charge, be made sensible from their very infancy of their sacred obligation of loyalty to their kings, of respect to their authority, and of submission to their laws, not only for wrath, but for conscience sake.ā ā But princes should not exact, and subjects should not affect to give them ecclesiastical jurisdiction. St. Athanasius quotes the following strong words from an epistle of the famous confessor Hosius, to Constantius, the Arian emperor: āCease, I beseech thee, and remember that thou art mortal. Fear the day of judgment, and meddle not with ecclesiastical matters; neither do thou command us in this kind, but rather learn them of us. To thee God hath committed the empire; to us he hath committed what belongs to the Church. And as he who, with a malicious eye, hath designs upon thine empire, opposeth the ordinance of God; so do thou also beware lest, by an improper interference in ecclesiastical matters, thou be made guilty of a great crime. For it is written, Give to CÄsar, &c. Therefore, neither is it lawful for us on earth to hold the empire, neither hast thou, O emperor, power over incense and sacred things.ā (St. Athansius, ep. ad solit. vitam agentes.) ā And St. Ambrose to Valentinian, the emperor, (who by the ill counsel of his mother Justina, an Arian, required of St. Ambrose to have one church in Milan made over to the Arian heretics) saith: āWe pay that which is CÄsarās to CÄsar, and that which is Godās to God. Tribute is CÄsarās; it is not denied. The Church is Godās; it cannot verily be yielded to CÄsar; because the temple of God cannot be CÄsarās right. Be it said, as all must allow to the honour of the emperor, for what is more honourable than that the emperor be said to be the son of the Church? A good emperor is within the Church, but not above the Church.ā (St. Ambrose, lib. v. epist. Orat. de Basil, trad.)
(2.) From thence he inferred the lawfulness of paying tribute to CƦsar (v. 21); Render therefore to CƦsar the things that are CƦsar's; not, "Give it him" (as they expressed it, v. 17), but, "Render it; Return," or "Restore it; if CƦsar fill the purses, let CƦsar command them. It is too late now to dispute paying tribute to CƦsar; for you are become a province of the empire, and, when once a relation is admitted, the duty of it must be performed. Render to all their due, and particularly tribute to whom tribute is due." Now by this answer,
Verses 15-22 The Pharisees sent their disciples with the Herodians, a party among the Jews, who were for full subjection to the Roman emperor. Though opposed to each other, they joined against Christ. What they said of Christ was right; whether they knew it or not, blessed be God we know it. Jesus Christ was a faithful Teacher, and a bold reprover. Christ saw their wickedness. Whatever mask the hypocrite puts on, our Lord Jesus sees through it. Christ did not interpose as a judge in matters of this nature, for his kingdom is not of this world, but he enjoins peaceable subjection to the powers that be. His adversaries were reproved, and his disciples were taught that the Christian religion is no enemy to civil government. Christ is, and will be, the wonder, not only of his friends, but of his enemies. They admire his wisdom, but will not be guided by it; his power, but will not submit to it.