“Dixisti enim : Purus est sermo meus, et mundus sum in conspectu tuo.”
“For thou hast said, My doctrine is pure, and I am clean in thine eyes.”
“You have said, ‘My doctrine is sound, and I am pure in Your sight.’”
“For you say, ‘My doctrine is pure. I am clean in your eyes.’”
“For thou sayest, My doctrine is pure, And I am clean in thine eyes.”
He chargeth Job with this, that he should say, that the thing which he spake was true, and that he was without sin in the sight of God.
Sight. Job had just said the reverse, chap. ix. 2. (St. Chrysostom)
II. He charges Job with saying that which he had not said (v. 4): Thou hast said, My doctrine is pure. And what if he had said so? It was true that Job was sound in the faith, and orthodox in his judgment, and spoke better of God than his friends did. If he had expressed himself unwarily, yet it did not therefore follow but that his doctrine was true. But he charges him with saying, I am clean in thy eyes. Job had not said so: he had indeed said, Thou knowest that I am not wicked (ch. 10 7); but he had also said, I have sinned, and never pretended to a spotless perfection. He had indeed maintained that he was not a hypocrite as they charged him; but to infer thence that he would not own himself a sinner was an unfair insinuation. We ought to put the best construction on the words and actions of our brethren that they will bear; but contenders are tempted to put the worst.
Verses 1-6 Zophar attacked Job with great vehemence. He represented him as a man that loved to hear himself speak, though he could say nothing to the purpose, and as a man that maintained falsehoods. He desired God would show Job that less punishment was exacted than he deserved. We are ready, with much assurance, to call God to act in our quarrels, and to think that if he would but speak, he would take our part. We ought to leave all disputes to the judgment of God, which we are sure is according to truth; but those are not always right who are most forward to appeal to the Divine judgment.