
She Was Angry at God on Christmas Eve—Then Jesus Said Something That Changed Her Heart - 5CFE
Written by Jame
Chapter 2: The Christmas Prayer She Was Afraid to Finish - 5CFE
The following chapters are an imagined fictional continuation of the original Christmas Eve story. Emily remained on the bench long after the church bells faded. The place where Jesus had knelt was qu
The following chapters are an imagined fictional continuation of the original Christmas Eve story.
Emily remained on the bench long after the church bells faded.
The place where Jesus had knelt was quiet now, but the warmth of His words lingered in her memory.
She looked at the photograph again.
"I'm still here," she repeated, almost testing whether the words were true.
A part of her wanted to feel grateful. Another part wanted to scream. Both feelings existed together, and for once she did not force herself to choose between them.
Across the street, the church doors opened, releasing a stream of warm light onto the snowy pavement.
A woman stepped outside carrying a small paper cup. She appeared to be in her sixties, with silver hair tucked beneath a knitted hat and a thick blue coat wrapped around her shoulders.
She noticed Emily sitting alone.
"Are you all right, dear?"
Emily almost answered automatically.
I'm fine.
Those two words had become her shield. She used them whenever relatives called, whenever neighbors asked about Christmas plans, and whenever strangers looked at her with sympathy.
But tonight she was tired of pretending.
"No," Emily said quietly. "I'm not."
The woman did not seem surprised.
"Would you like something warm?"
Emily hesitated before accepting the cup.
"Thank you."
"My name is Ruth," the woman said. "I help with the Christmas service. I came outside because I needed a little air."
Emily held the warm drink between her hands.
"I'm Emily."
Ruth sat at the opposite end of the bench, leaving enough distance for Emily to feel comfortable.
For several minutes, neither woman spoke.
Finally Ruth glanced at the photograph.
"Someone very special?"
Emily's throat tightened.
"My mother."
The words felt heavier than she expected.
"Her name was Grace."
Ruth nodded gently.
"Would you like to tell me about her?"
Emily stared at the photograph.
For weeks, everyone had asked how she was coping. Nobody had asked what her mother was like before illness entered their lives.
"She loved Christmas," Emily whispered. "Not because of the presents. She loved having everyone together. She said a house didn't need to be beautiful as long as people felt welcome inside it."
A faint smile appeared on Emily's face.
"She always burned the first batch of cookies. Every single year. And she always blamed the oven."
Ruth laughed softly.
Emily laughed too, then suddenly began crying.
"I'm sorry."
"You don't need to apologize."
"I haven't laughed about her in weeks. It feels wrong."
Ruth shook her head.
"Remembering something beautiful doesn't mean you've forgotten what hurts."
Emily looked toward the church.
"I was angry with God tonight."
"Were you?"
"I said terrible things. I questioned Him. I told Him I didn't understand why He let her die."
Ruth considered her words.
"Did your mother ever stop loving you when you were upset with her?"
"No."
"Then perhaps you already know something important about love."
Emily lowered her eyes.
The question followed her all the way home.
Deepen Your Scripture Study with Catholic Portal
Explore the complete 73-book Catholic Canon, original Hebrew and Greek interlinear texts, patristic commentaries, Daily Mass liturgical readings, and Catechism cross-references.

