
Chapter 7: The Question Nobody Could Answer - 5CFE
Written by Jame
After lunch, Emily helped Ruth clear the tables.
The hall had grown quieter, and soft Christmas music played near the kitchen.
"You seem a little lighter," Ruth observed.
Emily shook her head thoughtfully.
"Maybe. But I still don't understand why my mother had to die."
Ruth set down a stack of plates.
"I wish I could give you an answer."
"People keep telling me God needed another angel. Or that everything happened for a reason."
Emily's voice trembled.
"I know they're trying to help, but those words make me feel as though I'm not allowed to be devastated."
Ruth nodded.
"Sometimes people reach for explanations because they don't know how to sit beside suffering."
"Do you think God wanted this to happen?"
Ruth was silent for a moment.
"I don't know why your mother died when she did, Emily. And I wouldn't pretend to know God's private reasons."
Emily looked at her with surprise.
It was the first time someone had admitted uncertainty without trying to cover it with a comforting phrase.
"Then what am I supposed to believe?"
"Perhaps you don't have to settle every question today."
Ruth leaned against the counter.
"Faith doesn't always mean having an explanation. Sometimes it means bringing your unanswered questions into a relationship you haven't given up on."
Emily remembered the park bench.
"I told Jesus I was angry."
"And what happened?"
"He didn't turn away."
Ruth smiled gently.
"Then perhaps that is where you begin."
Emily looked through the window at the snow-covered street.
For the first time, she allowed herself to consider that uncertainty and faith might exist in the same heart.
Deepen Your Scripture Study with Catholic Portal
Explore the complete 73-book Catholic Canon, original Hebrew and Greek interlinear texts, patristic commentaries, Daily Mass liturgical readings, and Catechism cross-references.

